Young Deer's identity revealed

I've posted about pioneering Native filmmaker James Young Deer and his film White Fawn's Devotion before. Now an author has solved the mystery of his identity.

Who Was the Real James Young Deer?

The Mysterious Identity of the Pathè Producer Finally Comes to Light

"With his acting experience and technical know-how, Young Deer soon advanced to one of Pathé's leading filmmakers. His Indian identity served him well: no one in the cast or crew at that time would have taken orders from a black man."

By Angela AleissFew in Hollywood knew that James Young Deer, general manager of Pathé Frères West Coast Studio from 1911 to 1914, was really an imposter. After all, Young Deer had earned a reputation as the first Native American producer and had worked alongside D. W. Griffith, Fred J. Balshofer, and Mack Sennett. As one of Hollywood's pioneer filmmakers, Young Deer oversaw the production of more than 100 one-reel silent Westerns for Pathé, the world's largest production company with an American studio in Edendale in Los Angeles.

Young Deer was married to Lillian St. Cyr, a Winnebago Indian from Nebraska known as "Princess Red Wing" and star of Cecil B. DeMille's 1914 classic The Squaw Man. He boasted of a full-blooded Winnebago heritage similar to his wife: his birthplace became Dakota City, Nebraska, and his father was "Green Rainbow" from the Winnebago reservation. He claimed he attended the Carlisle Indian Industrial School in Pennsylvania, the first off-reservation Indian boarding school.

In a 2010 BBC Radio 3 segment, "James Young Deer: The Winnebago Film-Maker," no one—including this author—could unscramble Young Deer's murky past. Young Deer was elusive, and a search in his background leads to a maze of contradictions and discrepancies. But after ten months of poking through dusty archives and faded vital records and tracking down Lillian's relatives, the identity of this mysterious filmmaker finally came to light. His real name: James Young Johnson, born about April 1, 1878, in Washington, D.C., to mulatto parents George Durham Johnson and Emma Margaret Young.

"If Young Deer claimed to be Winnebago, he was lying to himself and others to promote himself," says David Smith, Winnebago historian, author, and former director of Indian Studies at Little Priest Tribal College in Nebraska. Smith has heard endless stories about Young Deer's supposed Winnebago heritage, and he's had enough. His reaction is understandable: Native American identity is an especially sensitive issue, and no Indian tribe wants their name appropriated by some wannabe.Comment:  Fortunately, the question of Young Deer's identity has a happy ending. It turns out he was Nanticoke, a state-recognized tribe in Delaware. So we don't have to rewrite film history and label him a fraud. Even if he didn't know it himself, he was a Native filmmaker.

For more on the subject, see The Best Indian Movies.

Below:  "Bison crew in Coytesville, NJ 1909 with Young Deer (center, right) and Red Wing standing to his left."