By Jess Wilson
Several wardrobe changes included a gold gladiator-style frock with a long blonde wig, and a full Native American-style get-up.
Activist Gray Wolf posted this photo along with his comments:
If she were "part" Native which I sincerely doubt, then she should KNOW better than to disrespect Native culture with such an insulting outfit! The defense of such behavior usually comes from those that do not have a clue as to what Native culture and tradition is really all about!
I don't understand the comments saying this is honoring anyone. When the cultures and traditions in question are being grossly distorted and sexualized, isn't that pretty much the same thing as saying wearing blackface is a compliment?
Tsalagi (Cherokee) do not wear headdress....So this would still be appropriation of culture as her culture has no headdress or war bonnet....Come on folks....LOL
I posted the photo on the NativeCelebs page and got more comments, some of which I answered:
Y'all understand that Cherokee is a completely different culture from Lakota and other Plains Indians, right? The argument that she's Cherokee so she can wear a Plains headdress is ridiculous. It's like saying she's Greek so she can wear a kilt or she's Scottish so she can wear a toga.
The fact that people think there's only one "Native culture" and they all wear headdresses is the problem, not the solution. If this is your argument, you're part of the problem too. Quit arguing that all Indians are the same and learn the differences!
And there's no "hatred" involved in criticism. It's like saying 2+2 = 4, not 5. Correcting math problems isn't hateful and neither is correcting false or misleading stereotypes.
That's something you've never understood, which is too bad. Pointing out mistakes so people do better next time is positive. It's a matter of explaining and educating, which most people understand are necessary steps for change.
And since 99% of our postings are positive even by your definition, we aren't about to apologize for the 1% that you consider "negative." We've posted 10-15 supportive items every day for several years straight, a record no one else can match. Until someone else does even better, we don't need anyone telling us how to be positive.
P.S. Anyone who's saying Cher is half Native is sadly mistaken. 1/16th or less would be closer to the mark. Which means she's like every other Indian wannabe: not Native.
For more on the subject, see Cher in a Headdress.
4 comments:
I wonder how the owners of the tribal casino felt about this.
http://www.theday.com/article/20140406/NWS01/140409771/-1/nws
At 67, Cher still has it
Now, Cher’s singing and Cher’s humor are all well and good, but she’s just as famous for her gonzo costumes. You have to give it to her: the woman mixes lavish and campy like no one else can. For the show opener, she donned a feathered headpiece so extravagant, it would make a peacock feel like a wallflower. For “Half Breed”—while performing at an Native American casino—she slipped into an outfit that mixed Indian influences with pure Vegas flamboyance.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2615995/Cher-turns-time-recycling-stage-look-four-decades-ago.html
If I Could Turn Back Time! Cher reincarnates her Native American-themed costume from 1973 on her U.S. tour
The 67-year-old pop icon, who's currently performing her Dressed To Kill tour dates in the US, took to the stage in a traditional Native American inspired get-up--just like the one she wore in her 1973 music video for Half-Breed (and subsequent tour).
Cher looked beautiful then and now! shes honoring the tribes not bringing them down!!! Whats wrong with you people??!!
Who gives a shit how she looks? She is a cultural appropriator that is enforcing damaging misrepresentative stereotypes. Those who think otherwise are obviously still stuck in their racist and colonialist mindset. White people don't get to define what is and isn't Native, only Natives can do that, and they CERTAINLY don't get to misrepresent Native cultures and get away without criticism. They deserve every ounce of it.
Post a Comment