December 12, 2008

"Grand Chief" Webber sent to jail

Five-Year Sentence for Grand ChiefU.S. Attorney Marietta Parker says a Wichita man who called himself “Grand Chief Thunderbird” has been sentenced to five years in federal prison for setting up a fraudulent scheme to sell memberships in a fictitious Indian tribe as a way for illegal immigrants to avoid deportation.

70-year-old Malcolm L. Webber of Wichita was convicted in a jury trial in August on one count of conspiracy to defraud the United States, two counts of harboring illegal aliens, two counts of possession of false identification documents, and one count of mail fraud.

Evidence presented at trial showed that thousands of people paid to become members of the Kaweah Indian Nation, a fictitious Indian tribe created by Webber. Buyers believed the memberships would make them U.S. citizens and keep them from being deported.

Webber was indicted in February 2007 after reports came in from Social Security offices, drivers license bureaus and law enforcement agencies in Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Missouri, Texas, Michigan, California, and other states that foreign nationals were showing up with documents purchased from Webber. The bearers were offering the documents as proof they were U.S. citizens. They were seeking Social Security cards, driver’s licenses and other forms of identification to which they claimed they were entitled. More than 300 sets of documents from the so-called Kaweah tribe were submitted to the Social Security office in Wichita by people claiming to be U.S. citizens.

The Bureau of Indian Affairs previously had determined that Webber was not a Native American Indian and his so-called Kaweah Indian Nation was not a Native American Indian tribe. The agency in 1984 denied a request by Webber for federal recognition of his Kaweah Indian Nation organization. The letter of denial stated that Webber was a “non-Indian” and that his organization had “no characteristics of an Indian Tribe which has maintained tribal relations from historical times.”
Comment:  Although it's not a legal crime to harm people's perception of Indians, it's arguably a moral crime. Webber deserves his sentence for that reason alone.

For more on the subject, see Kaweah Guilty of Fraud and "Chief Thundercloud IV" Arrested. Note that the news reports aren't certain whether Webber called himself Chief Thunderbird or Chief Thundercloud. Perhaps Webber wasn't certain himself. After all, one phony name is as good as another.

4 comments:

dmarks said...

Ah, the scam is over. It was the best chance David Yeagley and Ward Churchill had to become Indians.

Anonymous said...

As I have stated on this blog before: Indian frauds do actual and great harm to REAL Indians as, ultimately, it is we who have to bear the invariably widespread brunt of any unpopular opinions generated by the asinine antics of the myriad of phonies acting on behalf of themselves for whatever reason(s).

And with every act of Indian fraud there is always an incalculable amount of collateral damage; in this case, the harm done to the thousands of undocumented "aliens" who are already so thoroughly demonized by most of U.S. society.

Melvin Martin
Enrolled Member, Oglala Sioux Tribe
(of the Oglala Lakota Nation)

Anonymous said...

Most wannabes are harmless and often supportive of Indians in various ways, but as in 99.9% of human activities, if there is any way for one to advance themselves by peddling snake oil (a fully American tradition), than such fraudulent behavior will most likely occur.

Anonymous said...

And I quote:

"Melvin Martin said...

As I have stated on this blog before: Indian frauds do actual and great harm to REAL Indians as, ultimately, it is we who have to bear the invariably widespread brunt of any unpopular opinions generated by the asinine antics of the myriad of phonies acting on behalf of themselves for whatever reason(s).

And with every act of Indian fraud there is always an incalculable amount of collateral damage; in this case, the harm done to the thousands of undocumented "aliens" who are already so thoroughly demonized by most of U.S. society.

Melvin Martin
Enrolled Member, Oglala Sioux Tribe
(of the Oglala Lakota Nation)"

Hmmm...

In some circles, if I refer to myself as "Sioux," then I am acting in a fraudulent manner in terms of tribal "misidentification."

Feedback? MM