March 15, 2007

Comics picks and pans

In our discussion of A History of Natives in Comics, I asked the panelists to name what they considered the high and low points in Native comics. The only condition was they couldn't name their own comics or characters. Here's what they said:

Greg Reinhardt

High:  Turok

Low:  Tomahawk's fights against a giant robot Indian, an alien Indian, and a purple gorilla Indian

Richard Van Camp

High:  Scout, the Crow

Low:   COWBOYS & ALIENS

Michael Sheyahshe

High:  Forge, Street Wolf (an obscure independent character)

Low:  Scalphunter

Steve Sanderson

High:  Billy the Indian in Predator

Rob

High:  Thunderbird (for his historical significance), Dani Moonstar, Arak, the Indians in Alpha Flight

Low:  NFL SUPERPRO #6

Note:  Readers are welcome to submit their own high and low points.

3 comments:

writerfella said...

Writerfella here --
Count writerfella in as one more vote for TUROK, SON OF STONE as being one of the pinnacles of Native Americans in comics. And since writerfella only recently found in this very blog that Turok and Andar ostensibly were Kiowans, that then is not an element in his consideration, as he always had held such an opinion since encountering the comic as an adolescent...
All Best
Russ Bates
'writerfella'

voyageur said...

I've somehow missed most of these, including "Turok", but here goes anyway, from ones I've actually read:

Highs: Peace Party, Arak

Lows: Little Hiawatha from "Walt Disney Comics and Stories" digest.

voyageur said...

Postscriptum:

"mixed": Eagle Free from "Prez". On the downside, he looks so stereotypical, lives in a stereotypical setting and has those amazing animal powers of the "Native Americans have Aquaman-like powers with the woodland creatures" stereotype.

On the upside, he lacks any speech stereotypes and any drunken grandfathers, doesn't have an attitude problem, and he holds an unprecedented high position of political power.