I glanced at LONE RANGER #1-2 but didn't buy them. Although the story seems a little light, John Cassady's artwork looks gorgeous. Here's what the Lone Ranger Fan Club thinks of #1:
There are many details that are faithful to the established character mixed with new elements, such as the father. There is some course language that is questionable for a character of the Lone Ranger’s integrity. At one point in the story Tonto makes an appearance and does something that is way out of character. It’s the biggest disappointment in an otherwise superb story.
Over all, the creative team has done an exceptional job blending tradition and new storytelling in a comic that will be pleasing to a wide range of readers from the older Lone Ranger fans to the young comic book connoisseurs. We eagerly await the next installments of this episodic adventure!
This is a clever bit of humor. Writer Brett Matthews (and Tonto, since he's the one speaking) is smart enough to use a stereotype only to subvert it. It's an example of laughing with Indians, not at them.
5 comments:
Writerfella here --
That's likely the best representation of Tonto in any of the various incarnations so far. If Lone is younger than Tonto, then we can understand what is the basis of their continuing relationship. He has adopted John Reid. That is in keeping with many occurrences between Europeans and Natives, even in writerfella's own Kiowa family. I believe this expands the mythos.
I believe a previous comic book portrayed Tonto as an angry, independent Indian who punched the Lone Ranger at one point. And the 2003 TV movie made Tonto the Ranger's mentor, though they were the same age. So I'm not sure this comic is offering anything new about him.
Writerfella here --
Mentoring and fatherhood are not the same. Obi-Wan Kenobi was a mentor; Darth Vader was a father, albeit after being rescued by his son late in life. Native 'adoption' meant far more than is realized in modern society. The person so honored was adjudged to be truly worthy and the adoptive parent intended that such a person must not be allowed to go on in life without realizing his worth. Persons that writerfella has adopted in such fashion have gone on to great things.
All Best
Russ Bates
'writerfella'
I agree mentoring and fathering aren't the same. That's why I used the word "mentor" and didn't use the word "father" or "fatherhood."
It's not clear the new Tonto is even going to mentor John Reid, much less "father" or adopt him. You're reading a lot into my brief description.
Writerfella here --
As you read a lot from merely having "glanced" at that comic...
All Best
Russ Bates
'writerfella'
Post a Comment